BOK logo

Be wary of trust disclaimers, ATO warns

Beneficiaries are urged to understand the tax effect of entitlements in the wake of a recent High Court decision.


Taxpayers should be wary of disclaiming trust entitlements and ensure they understand the tax implications of any benefits before the end of the financial year, the ATO has warned.

It is encouraging trustees and beneficiaries to give themselves time to seek advice in the wake of a crucial High Court decision, Commissioner of Taxation v Carter, in April.

The decision upheld the ATO’s view that beneficiaries who had validly disclaimed their rights to trust entitlements after the end of the financial year were nevertheless liable to be taxed on them.

“As the end of the financial year approaches, it is important … for trustees and beneficiaries to be aware of the taxation consequences which flow from trust entitlements,” the ATO said.

“The ATO also encourages beneficiaries of trusts to exercise particular caution before disclaiming an entitlement from a trust. Further, if they have a tax obligation arising from an entitlement and the entitlement is not subsequently distributed to them, to seek advice as to how to compel the trust to distribute that amount.”

In a decision impact statement on the Carter case, the ATO said the High Court had provided useful “clarity”.

“The High Court decision settles an important practical question as to how trust income is to be brought to tax when relevant trust entitlements are disclaimed in a legally effective manner sometime after financial year end,” said the ATO.

“It tells us that such disclaimers do not disturb what would otherwise be the tax result. Beneficiaries who have an interest in, or entitlement to, trust income should now take this into account if they were otherwise considering not accepting that interest or entitlement and instead looking to disclaim it.”

The ATO had pursued the case, it said, because “the uncertainty in how the tax law operated when a beneficiary disclaims an entitlement was significant to tax administration”.

It had two particular concerns:

- “That a beneficiary could intentionally avoid the incidence of tax by disclaiming an entitlement after year end and that, in certain cases, a late disclaimer could have been part of a scheme with the effect that the underlying income was never taxed to anyone,” the ATO said.

- “The actions of such a beneficiary could have adverse implications for others with an interest in the trust, without them knowing or having a say in this.”

The ATO said the court’s decision did not adversely impact trust beneficiaries who wished to retain their trust entitlements and advised them to be aware of steps they could take to call for payment.

The office has withdrawn its previous guidance on the matter (Interpretative Decision 2010/85).




Philip King
15 June 2022

Want to know more?

Do you have a question about something you've read in this article? Need more information? Want to book an appointment? Simply let us know below and we'll get back to you ASAP.


In the preparation of this website every effort has been made to provide accurate and timely information. However, errors can occur and applicable laws and regulations may change.

The information contained in the site is general and is not intended to serve as advice. No warranty is given as to the reliability of any information.

Users are encouraged to consult with professional advisers for advice before making any decisions that affect their own interests.

Bourke O’Brien Kennedy disclaims all and any liability to any person as to the consequences of anything done or omitted to be done by any person in reliance whether wholly or partially, upon any information contained in this website.

Links on this website are to resources managed by other parties over whom Bourke O’Brien Kennedy has no control. As such, Bourke O’Brien Kennedy accepts no responsibility as to the accuracy of any statement, opinion or advice contained in any of the supplied information and readers should rely on their own enquiries before making any decisions affecting their own interests.

Privacy Policy

We will only use the information you provide to us to respond to your requests and provide you with information about Bourke O’Brien Kennedy services.

Whenever you receive information from us electronically, you will always have an opportunity to request not to receive the information again and your wishes will be respected.

If you send us a curriculum vitae (CV) to apply for a position with Bourke O’Brien Kennedy, we will only use that information to consider you for available opportunities.

We do not share personal information with third parties except as necessary to carry out our business or as required by law or other processes. We do not sell personal information. All personnel with access to personal information ensure to maintain its confidentiality.

If you have questions or comments about anything to do with our website, please do not hesitate to contact us at